Review of The Hobbit

Updated: Nov 12
by

JRR Tolkien
Illustrated by Alan Lee
About 300 pages
ISBN # 0-395-87346-0
Copyright 1937, 1966, 1994, 1997
Grade Level: 7-9
Available in libraries and most bookstores.
Having just finished The Hobbit, I am once again struck by the pure creativity of J.R.R. Tolkien. As a cornerstone of the High Fantasy subgenre, this book doesn't just tell a story; it builds an entire world from the ground up, complete with its own languages, lore, distinct cultures, and a deep sense of history. Tolkien’s imagination operates on a scale that few authors have ever matched. I chose a hardcover copy with a variety of pictures by Lee because the book felt more solid, which I think the tale deserves.
The Hobbit, as well as all the stories that go with Tolkien’s Middle-earth, are high fantasy. That is a subcategory of fantasy. People speak of "regular" or low fantasy; they are usually referring to stories that are anchored to our own familiar world (the primary world), where magical elements intrude, hide, or exist just beneath the surface. High fantasy, on the other hand, operates on an entirely different structural level. Regular fantasy asks, "What if magic existed in our world?", whereas high fantasy builds an entirely new universe from scratch and asks, "How does this entire world function under its own distinct laws, history, and grand mythologies?"

As someone who teaches business writing, where the primary goal is to keep communication short, direct, plain, and immediately actionable, reading Tolkien is a fascinating exercise in contrast. His style sits on the exact opposite end of the spectrum. He does not rush to the point. Instead, he paints lavish descriptions of landscapes, delves into ancestral lineages, and lingers over the details of a quiet evening in Bag End or the ancient roots of a mountain pass.
Many people remark that Tolkien’s work isn't meant for readers who get easily distracted, and I find that to be true. His pacing belongs to an era far removed from today’s short attention spans. Reading his work requires active presence and full immersion; if your mind wanders, it's easy to lose the thread. I'll admit that I found myself getting distracted at times while reading, as his dense prose asks more of the reader than a quick, modern page-turner.
Yet, despite, or perhaps because of, this deliberate pacing, I absolutely love his work.
I’ve long turned to the film adaptations of Middle-earth whenever I feel lonely or depressed. There is a deep, comforting warmth in these stories that acts as a balm during difficult times. Reading The Hobbit provided that same profound comfort. Tolkien’s world offers a gentle reminder that even the smallest, most unassuming individuals can carry immense courage, and that light persists even in the darkest places.

My favorite part of the story, in both the book and the films, is the interplay between Bilbo and Gandalf. I love how Gandalf manages Bilbo with such intuitive wisdom—perceiving his distinct personality and knowing precisely when to offer insights that Bilbo needs to reflect on. Rather than avoiding difficult truths or backing down, Gandalf addresses accountability in a clever, roundabout manner that bypasses Bilbo's natural defenses, leaving him far more open to learning and growth. While Gandalf approaches Bilbo with dry wit, playful trickery, and clever psychological nudges to push him out of his comfortable rut, his approach with Frodo in future books is noticeably different; it is far more solemn, direct, and emotionally grounded.
While holding a book requires more focus than watching a film, the emotional payoff of stepping into Bilbo Baggins’ journey remains unmatched. The Hobbit is a timeless adventure, rich in detail, heart, and imagination, and it remains a masterpiece worth taking the time to truly inhabit.



Comments